Waterside Towers, United Nations International School
Architect: Davis, Brody & Associates
Address: 25 Waterside Plaza, 24-50 FDR Drive
Use: Mixed (residential, retail, school, parking, public plaza)
By the 1960s slum clearance, urban renewal projects were beginning to face opposition as the grand vision for social housing in New York City was looking less utopian and more damaging to the urban fabric. One of the biggest hurdles new projects faced was tenant relocation and projects that did not involve displacement were more feasible. Two residential developments in this survey sought to create affordable housing towers on land that was previously undeveloped, Morrisania Air Rights in the Bronx and Waterside Plaza in Kips Bay.
Waterside Plaza replaced abandoned piers that were crumbling into the East River with a platform on which a new mixed-use community would be built. Waterside was created for a mix of income groups and family sizes, with the northern tower (34 stories) financed by FHA-insured multifamily housing loans for moderate-income families with another quarter for lower income. The other three towers (40 stories) financed with low-interest mortgages through city tax abatements, keeping the apartments affordable for middle income tenants. Construction started in 1971, ten years after it was first proposed, with the laying 2000 steel piles sunk 80 feet in the riverbed to support the poured-in-place concrete platform. The platform featured two levels of parking from the street with towers, townhouses, a public plaza, a school and retail above, designed by Davis, Brody & Associates. The four towers range from 31 to 37 stories and are clad in dark brown brick, described in the AIA Guide to New York City as "cut and carved cubism" with cantilevered upper floors and vertical strips of windows.
The stark geometricism of the towers recalls less the additive, volumetric formal qualities of brutalism than the subtractive, carved compositions of New York’s great Art Deco skyscrapers of Raymond Hood and Ralph Walker. Though unstrained by the setback regulations of the 1916 zoning laws that helped to spur the older sculptural buildings, Davis Brody & Associates reverse the orientation of their four towers to create top-heavy cubist forms that utilize simple subtractions of 90 and 45 degree masses to create complex and thoroughly attractive towers that have managed to maintain the aesthetic impact of their form despite changing styles. Like many of their contemporaries, Davis, Brody recall the walls and towers of Northern Italian hill towns, merging these associations with progressive social aspirations and post-war modernist urbanism, all rendered in brown masonry units. The five story wall along the FDR Drive, the most superficially brutalist part of the project with its thick piers and heavy projections, both reinforces the medievalism of the design - a walled city, cloister, or castle - and serves to isolate the sprawling plaza within from the sounds of the city. The plaza inside, which spills towards the east river and for the first time in post-war New York celebrates the city’s waters not for their economic value but for the recreational vistas they afford, successfully recreates the spirit of old European plazas that post-war architects continuously, and usually unsuccessfully, attempted to conjure. Despite the brick cladding, the development is true brutalism: an ambitious urban renewal, progressive social project merging medieval and technocratic, standardized material with strong materiality, sculptural form, and modernist urbanism, all working together to form a distinct environment that is apart from the city but embraces the opportunities that New York’s geography and politics afford.
The only building on the site to break away from the brick that the plaza, towers, and townhouses are composed of, is the United Nations International School, a low-rise, cantilevered concrete building with an internal courtyard, designed by Harrison, Abramovitz & Harris.
The Mitchell-Lama funded complex has 1,470 apartments in the four towers and is the only development in the city east of the FDR Drive, isolated from the surrounding neighborhood by the six-lane highway. The only access is by a pedestrian overpass at 25th Street or the northbound lane on the FDR. Furthermore, the United Nations School on the south side of the plaza cuts off the pedestrian path that runs along the river, forcing joggers and bikers away from the waterfront and around the parking lot entrance along the highway.
Waterside Added to the Watch List of NYC Landmarks. Waterside Plaza, 2004.
Sherwood, Roger. Waterside Project Summary. housingprototypes.org, 2002.